News - News Agency Of Nigeria

Medical director prays Appeal Court to quash his rape conviction (Page 1,909)

By Taiye Agbaje

The Medical Director of Optimal Cancer Care Foundation, Dr Olufemi Olaleye, has asked the Court of Appeal to set aside his conviction by the lower court over alleged rape of minor.
Olaleye, in a notice of appeal filed by his lawyer, Dr Kemi Pinheiro, SAN, said that the Ikeja Sexual Offences and Domestic Violence Court was wrong to have relied on the evidence presented by the prosecution against him.
The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that the court, presided over by Justice Rahman Oshodi in the charge number: ID/20289C/2022 had, on Oct. 24, sentenced Olaleye to life imprisonment for alleged defilement of his wife’s niece claimed to be a 16-year old.
However, in the appeal dated and filed on Nov. 24 at the Appeal Court sitting in Lagos State, the appellant, through his lawyer, gave 35 grounds why his appeal should be allowed.
In a copy of the notice of appeal made available to newsmen in Abuja on Wednesday, Pinheiro argued that “the lower court erred in law when, in the absence of any direct evidence, it held that the alleged victim of the crime was a child of 16 at the time of the offence.”
He said that the prosecution did not tender any documentary evidence in support of its case that the alleged victim of the crime was 16 years.
In proving this fact, the lawyer argued that the prosecution had the onerous duty of presenting the birth certificate of the complainant which would have served as conclusive proof of her age.
But throughout the trial, he said neither the prosecution nor the complainant put forward any documentary proof of the alleged survivor’s age, other than the oral evidence of the witnesses.
The lawyer also argued that contrary to the submission that the alleged victim was consistent in her evidence that Olaleye raped her, her evidence was riddled with inconsistencies.
Pinheiro said the alleged survivor never accused the appellant of rape before the police who interviewed her when the alleged events were still very fresh in her mind.
He said it was only four months after the alleged incident occurred that she turned around and alleged that the appellant raped her.
According to him, the court ought to have been suspicious of the time frame between her statements to the police and the Gender Department of the police.
He further argued that the lower court ought not to have relied on the evidence of PW5, Dr Akinbunmi Oyebimpe of MIRABEL, in convicting and sentencing the appellant.
He argued that contrary to Oyebimpe’s finding, the examination carried out on the alleged survivor by PW5 was done months after the alleged offence was committed.
“Even though the offences were alleged to have occurred between 2020 and 2021, the medical certificate issued by PW5 clearly showed that the alleged survivor was being examined in respect of a sexual assault that occurred in March, 2022.
“In the face of this material contradiction, it was wrong of the court to have held that the evidence of PW5 corroborated that of the alleged survivor.
“Since the outcome of PW5’s examination did not indict the appellant, the finding of the court is erroneous and ought not to be sustained,” the lawyer said.
He equally faulted the court to have relied on the testimony of the 1st prosecution witness (PW1), who was Olaleye’s wife and also a complainant, which he said was tainted with malice on the events that occurred in the presence of CSP Patricia Amadi and Aunty Tessy without hearing from these vital witnesses.
According to him, the honourable lower court erred in law when it held that it did not “…believe that Aunty Tessy was a vital witness,” while believing the testimony of PW1 and PW2 (prosecutrix).
He said Aunty Tessy was an independent witness who had received the allegations leveled against PW1 and PW2.
He contended that Olaleye’s wife, Aderemi (PW1), had demonstrated to be holding a grudge against the appellant.
“As a result, the court ought to have been cautious in relying on her evidence which had a high probability of being tainted,” he added.
He also challenged the finding of the trial court on two fronts.
“Firstly, PW1 not being present when the appellant allegedly had sexual intercourse with the alleged survivor could not have corroborated the evidence of the alleged survivor because corroborative evidence ought to come from a person who directly witnessed the events as they occurred.
“Secondly, any corroborative evidence ought to come from an independent source.
“Having demonstrated during trial that PW1 stood to benefit from the appellant’s conviction, it was wrong of the court to have relied on her tainted testimony in finding that her evidence corroborated that of the complainant,” the lawyer argued, among others.
He insisted that Aderemi (PW1) was demonstrably a tainted and interested witness and as such, her evidence was manifestly unreliable.
Pinheiro, who sought four reliefs, urged the appellate court to make an order setting aside the decision of the lower court.
He also sought an order setting aside the conviction of and quashing the sentence against the appellant by the lower court.
The lawyer equally sought an order discharging and acquitting Olaleye of the offences preferred against him.(NAN)(www.nannews.ng)
======
Edited by Sadiya Hamza

Medical director prays Appeal Court to quash his rape conviction

By: isaac aregbesola

On: December 6, 2023

In: Judiciary

With: 0 Comments

By Taiye Agbaje The Medical Director of Optimal Cancer Care Foundation, Dr Olufemi Olaleye, has asked the Court of Appeal to set aside his conviction by the lower court over alleged rape of minor. Olaleye, in a notice of appeal filed by his lawyer, Dr Kemi Pinheiro, SAN, said thatContinue Reading

Sen. Aliyu Abdullahi, Minister of State for Agriculture

FG to strengthen partnership with institute, others on proper soil management

By: Afonne Emmanuel

On: December 6, 2023

In: Agriculture, Environment

With: 0 Comments

By Akpan Glory/Felicia Imohimi The Federal Government has pledged to continue to support the Nigeria Institute of Soil Science (NISS) and other public and private entities to ensure proper management of soil and water to achieve food security. Sen. Aliyu Abdullahi, Minister of State for Agriculture, said this at theContinue Reading

Yuletide: Organisation to light 85-feet Christmas tree in FCT

By: Afonne Emmanuel

On: December 6, 2023

In: Entertainment, General News

With: 0 Comments

By Gift Bayo JAV Christmas Village is set to light the tallest Christmas tree in Africa, standing at 85-feet tall with 500,000 bobs as part of the Christmas grand celebrations. Amb. Stephanie Nnadi, Chief Executive Officer, One Percent International, said this at a pre event news conference on Tuesday inContinue Reading

Minister tasks radiologists on data security

By: Muhyideen Jimoh

On: December 6, 2023

In: Health

With: 0 Comments

By Aderogba George The Minister of Health and Social Welfare, Prof. Ali Pate, has challenged radiologists to identify challenges impeding data security to address increased cases of litigations from patients against members. The minister gave the charge on Monday in Abuja at the 6th Annual General Meeting (AGM) and ScientificContinue Reading

Surgeons perform free joint replacement surgeries on indigent persons

By: Muhyideen Jimoh

On: December 6, 2023

In: Health

With: 1 Comment

By Aderogba George Some surgeons under the aegis of Nigerian Orthopaedic Association on Monday in Abuja began the conduct of joint replacement surgeries for six indigent people in Abuja. The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) this was part of the activities lined up for the 46th Annual General Meeting (AGM)Continue Reading

Implants: Association urges FG to subsidize cost

By: Muhyideen Jimoh

On: December 6, 2023

In: Health

With: 0 Comments

By Aderogba George The Nigerian Orthopaedic Association has urged the Federal Government to subsidise the cost of implants and make surgeries accessible to ordinary Nigerians who needed them. The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that implants are the metals used to fix fractures, while prosthesis are the thingsContinue Reading

Public Building: Commission calls on organisations to comply with laws for PWDs

By: isaac aregbesola

On: December 6, 2023

In: Data & Analysis

With: 0 Comments

By Collins Yakubu-Hammer The National Commission for Persons with Disabilities (NCPWD) has called on organisations across the country to ensure compliance to accessibility law and regulations to make provisions for Persons with Disabilities (PWDs) to access their buildings. The Executive Secretary of the Commission, Mr James Lalu, made the callContinue Reading

Military’ll not deliberately attack innocent citizens -Women group

By: isaac aregbesola

On: December 6, 2023

In: Defence/Security

With: 0 Comments

By Sumaila Ogbaje A peace advocacy group, Women Action Alliance (WAA), has called for calm over the unfortunate drone attack that killed scores of civilians at Tudun Biri community in Kaduna State. The group, in a statement by the Convener, Miriam Sanni, on Wednesday in Abuja, said the ArmedContinue Reading

Sports minister hails Super Falcons WAFCON qualification

By: Muhyideen Jimoh

On: December 6, 2023

In: General News, Sports

With: 0 Comments

By Muhyideen Jimoh The Minister of Sports Development, Sen. John Owan Enoh has hailed the Super Falcons on their successful qualification for the 2024 African Women’s Cup of Nations (WAFCON) slated for Morocco. The minister said the team displayed an impressive level of determination and teamwork, securing vital victories duringContinue Reading

French minister expresses support for EFCC’s anti-graft war

By: isaac aregbesola

On: December 6, 2023

In: General News

With: 0 Comments

By Isaac Aregbesola French’s Minister of the Interior and Overseas, Laurent Baile, has expressed support for the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) in its fight against economic and financial crimes and other acts of corruption. EFCC Spokesperson, Dele Oyewale, said in statement in Abuja that Baile made the disclosureContinue Reading

Follows Us

Medical director prays Appeal Court to quash his rape conviction (Page 1,909)